| 1 | Nightstalker |
| 2 | Ted Bundy Song |
| 3 | Sniper in the Sky |
| 4 | Montreal Massacre |
| 5 | Zodiak |
| 6 | What the Hell Did You Do?! ?! |
| 7 | Boston Strangler |
| 8 | Mary Bell |
| 9 | Mary Bell (Reprise) |
| 10 | Killing Spree (Postal Killer) |
| 11 | Is It Soup Yet? |
| 12 | White Hen Decapitator |
| 13 | Howard Unrah (What Have You Done Now?!) |
| 14 | Gacy's Lot |
| 15 | There Was a Young Man Who Blew up a Plane |
| 16 | Vampire of D?sseldorf |
| 17 | Shotgun Peterson |
| 18 | What's That Smell? |
| 19 | Edmond Kemper Had a Horrible Temper |
| 20 | What the Heck, Richard Speck |
| 21 | Albert Was Worse Than Any Fish in Then Sea |
| 22 | Fishtales |
| 23 | Behind the Walls of Sleep |
| 24 | Slaughter Thy Poser |
| 25 | Freeze Dried Man |
