| 1 | Serenade |
| 2 | Just a Wearyin' for You |
| 3 | Ghost Riders in the Sky |
| 4 | Holy Thou Art |
| 5 | Perfect Day |
| 6 | Whoopee Ti Yi Yo |
| 7 | Mule Train |
| 8 | Red Rosey Bush |
| 9 | Great Day |
| 10 | Strange Music |
| 11 | Blind Ploughman |
| 12 | Ave Maria |
| 13 | Lost Chord |
| 14 | Rodger Young |
| 15 | Danny Boy |
| 16 | Ich Leibe Dich |
| 17 | With These Hands |
| 18 | Cork Leg |
| 19 | Palms |
| 20 | Sylvia Columbia |
| 21 | Give Us This Day Our Daily Bread |
| 22 | In the Still of the Night |
| 23 | Isn't This a Night for Love |
| 24 | Somewhere in the Night |
| 25 | Out of the Night |
| 26 | Without a Song |
| 27 | Praise the Lord and Pass the Ammunition |
| 28 | Berceuse |
| 29 | Panis Angelicus |
| 30 | Trees |
| 31 | Song of the Flea |
| 32 | Close |
| 33 | Gorgeous Alexander |
| 34 | Dream |
| 35 | Holy City |
| 36 | Rosary |
| 37 | Dansando O Samba |
| 38 | Bethany College Alma Mater |
| 39 | Laughing Song |
| 40 | Because |
| 41 | Agnus Dei |
| 42 | Joy to the World |
| 43 | Good King Wenceslas |
| 44 | Away in a Manger |
| 45 | Silent Night |
| 46 | Little Town of Bethlehem |
| 47 | Hark! The Herald Angels Sing |
| 48 | First Noel |
| 49 | Holy Night |
| 50 | Come, All Ye Faithful |
| 51 | God Rest Ye Merry, Gentlemen |
| 52 | Deck the Halls With Boughs of Holly |
| 53 | White Christmas |
| 54 | Jingle Bells |
