Mulcahy was the front man and main songwriter for alternative rock band Miracle Legion in the 1980s to mid 1990s. Mulcahy also fronted Polaris, the house band for the mid 1990s alternative television series The Adventures of Pete & Pete (1993-96) and perhaps best remembered for the song "Hey Sandy," which was featured in the opening credits of the show.
| 1 | All For The Best - Thom Yorke |
| 2 | Ashamed Of The Story I Told - The National |
| 3 | Everything's Coming Undone - Michael Stipe |
| 4 | Love's The Only Thing That Shuts Me Up - David Berkeley |
| 5 | The Backyard - Dinosaur Jr |
| 6 | Micon The Icon - Chris Harford And The Band Of Changes |
| 7 | Bill Jocko - Frank Black |
| 8 | Little Man - Vic Chesnutt |
| 9 | Ciao My Shining Star - Unbelievable Truth |
| 10 | I Have Patience - Butterflies Of Love |
| 11 | Cookie Jar - Chris Collingwood |
| 12 | The Quiet One - Frank Turner |
| 13 | In Pursuit Of Your Happiness - Rocket From The Tombs |
| 14 | Wake Up Whispering - Ben Kweller |
| 15 | I Woke Up In The Mayflower - Josh Rouse |
| 16 | Paradise - The Autumn Defense |
| 17 | Happy Birthday Yesterday - Hayden |
| 18 | We're Not In Charleston Anymore - Juliana Hatfield |
| 19 | Sailors And Animals - Mercury Rev |
| 20 | She Watches Over Me - Elvis Perkins |
| 21 | A World Away From This One - Sean Watkins |